New Phone Number

(937) 303-8800
Press 1 if you’re here to pick up an order you’ve already placed.
Press 2 to place a new order. This will put you in a cue if there are other callers ahead of you. No more busy signals!

The old number will still work, but due to technical difficulties, it is constantly dropping phone calls. Thank you for your patience while we are working with the phone company to remedy the situation.

Changes @Bennys

Due to the governor’s orders, we are implementing the following changes…

  • We’re all curbside! Online orders are best, but we’re now set up to take payment info and process credit cards over the phone. If you wish to pay cash, please do your best to bring exact change.
    We have 34 numbered parking spots. Please park and call the number listed on the sign by your parking spot and we will run your order to your car! 🙂
  • In order to maintain the safest (socially distanced) environment possible in our kitchens, we have temporarily trimmed our menu down to the most popular items. It will enable us to serve you in a more timely manner, while also protecting our staff members, their families, and the community by social distancing in our kitchens. This was a necessary change in order to space out our staff inside the kitchen. As we settle into these changes, we look forward to offering some of our other popular menu items on a weekly basis.
    Benny’s Pizza Curbside Menu

We thank you for your understanding and continued patronage during this difficult time!

New Hours

Sunday 11am-8pm
Monday 11am-9pm
Tuesday 11am-9pm
Wednesday 11am-9pm
Thursday 11am-9pm
Friday 11am-10pm
Saturday 11am-10pm

Safest way to order is our Online Curbside Pickup – You don’t even have to come inside! We’ll run it to your car when you get here =)

Curbside for Online Orders

We’ve numbered our parking spots so online pickup orders can be brought to your vehicle, limiting the exchange of money & credit cards. Phoned in orders are still permitted to be picked up inside the building.

Please order online! For the safety of everyone in the community, we’re encouraging online ordering with curbside pickup.

10% off all online pickup orders: Use code ONLINE10

We are still open for phone orders and coming inside for pickup, but are trying to reduce the number of people that can build up in our carryout lobby.

Carryout Open

The dining room and bars have been closed, but we will remain open for Carryout as long as we’re able!

Use code ONLINE10 at checkout for 10% off your online order!
(Discount only valid for online orders)

For your safety:

  • Online orders are best! (no exchanging of $$, cards, pens, etc). If you order online, you can call when you arrive and we will run your order out to your car!
  • If ordering on the phone, please only send one healthy person in to pick up & pay for your order.
  • We will constantly sanitize high contact surfaces.
  • We will not allow anyone to work at Benny’s that is showing symptoms or has a member of the same household showing symptoms as outlined by the CDC.

This is new territory for everyone. We will do everything we can to continue providing everyone with the best food and customer service!

Eli’s Cheesecake

We are proudly serving slices of Eli’s Cheesecake at the register for carry out! Slices are just $2.99 (carry out only) and you can pick from Original, Chocolate Chip, or Strawberry Swirl. Take some home today! =)