New Menu

Come see our new menu! Here are a few new highlights…

  • Buffalo Chicken Macaroni & Cheese
  • Chicken Ranchero Pizza
  • Braided Pretzel Twists with Beer Cheese
  • Traditional Potato Skins (yes, we still have Benny’s Pizza Skins!)
  • New Naples Pasta Salad
  • Chicken Salad Sub
  • Amazing Reuben Dip

… and a whole lot more. Come on in and check it out.

See you at Benny’s Pizza!

Benny’s Live Music March 2017

Friday, 3/3/17 7:30-11:30 Scott Arnold
Saturday, 3/4/17 7:30-11:30 Discount Blues
Friday, 3/10/17 7:30-11:30 Jimmy Forbis
Saturday, 3/11/17 7:30-11:30 Matt Steidel
Friday, 3/17/17 3pm-7pm
Byrd Manring
JT Hillier
Saturday, 3/18/17 7:30-11:30 RMT
Friday, 3/24/17 7:30-11:30 Gold Match Band
Saturday, 3/25/17 7:30-11:30 Eric Yinger
Friday, 3/31/17 7:30-11:30 Ed & Abby

Dates and times are subject to change without notice.

CYO Pasta Tuesdays ALL DAY!

Create your own pasta Tuesdays are back at Benny’s for a limited time and last ALL DAY LONG! Choose your pasta, favorite homemade sauce, meat, and fresh veggies.

Dine in only – Not available for carry out.

Come join us in the dine in building for $2 Thursdays this fall & winter!


Our $2 Tuesday Happy Hour will be switching back to Thursdays this week from 4pm -9pm! It is no longer on Tuesdays. Come join us!


Eli’s Cheesecake

We are proudly serving slices of Eli’s Cheesecake at the register for carry out! Slices are just $2.99 (carry out only) and you can pick from Original, Chocolate Chip, or Strawberry Swirl. Take some home today! =)